Monthly Archives: September 2013

Why I find it unethical to cite books you haven’t read…

Why I find it unethical to cite books you haven’t read that you see mentioned in other books. This is an example from the Dobelli case but it is general. I spent 2 years reading books and papers on the history of medicine, taking notes. Then cited the author. About 60 hours of work for 1 citation. Dobelli mentions my argument, cuts/pastes the citation from my text, then cites him separately (in a discussion that is overall exposition of my argument). The argument would be “it is not your text, but Burch”. It is. The work of a researcher should be respected.

(Note that I kept reading until “saturation” of finding same points shared by many authors, then stopped” The only ambiguous point is what is found on Wikipedia: does one cite Wikipedia? What if the page changes?

via Timeline Photos | Facebook.