SKIN IN THE GAME and OUR FRAUD DETECTOR

SKIN IN THE GAME and OUR FRAUD DETECTOR
+ Have you ever wondered why people are upset by CEO compensation, sometimes >200x that of the average employee, but not if an entrepreneur makes the same amount of money; nor are they upset with singers, authors, or performers?
+ The economist Thomas Sowell found this an aberration. His argument is that a CEO is not harming you; he is not sponsored by the taxpayer (or let us grant him that for this argument). But Sowell and the others apologists of CEO pay are missing the fact that our naturalistic fraud detector may be picking up something quite severe. A CEO has inverse skin in the game; his losses are transferred to the shareholder (as he keeps the upside with stock options and stick others with the downside). As I said in Antifragile, he is no entrepreneur (or artist where thousands are sacrificing their lives, so entering the profession cannot be done rationally on economic grounds).
+ We also detect that a CEO is largely an actor. Just look at one on TV for a split second.
+ So our ecological instinct is effective there in smelling something unfair; it is more powerful than that of regular economists who need a more sophisticated understanding of contract theory/asymmetry to get the point.
+ Note that in some countries where wealth has a bad name, it is often because it is associated with rent seeking. In the US, perception is different because wealth is traditionally associated with risk taking.
+ Correct me if I am wrong, but it seems that societies give respect to people who have skin in the game (but not exclusively), and have a moral repulsion towards those who have inverse skin in the game.

via: Facebook

The Precautionary Principle applied to Climate problems in the presence of model error

 

https://twitter.com/nntaleb/status/622764064977104896

https://twitter.com/nntaleb/status/622752410486874112

The Precautionary Principle applied to Climate problems in the presence of model error. pic.twitter.com/WpLqvzqHpr
And this is the mathematical backup of why more skepticism should increase precaution, not other way around https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/50282823/mathbehindpp.pdf

Daniel Kahneman: ‘What would I eliminate if I had a magic wand? Overconfidence’ | The Guardian

Photograph: Richard Saker

“I’m far on the left of the spectrum in Israeli politics and always have been,” he says. “I hated the notion of occupation since the very beginning. My first memories from after the 67 war are travelling with my children in the occupied territories. There were awnings over groceries stores with Hebrew lettering advertising Osem noodles. I couldn’t bear it. I thought that was dreadful because I remembered German lettering in France. I have very strong feelings about Israel as an occupier.”Despite this, Kahneman has found it impossible to envisage a settlement that will satisfy both sides. “I don’t believe in the power of rational argument in this context,” he says, with an air of resignation. He mentions one occasion when he was visited at his university by a Palestinian academic after 67. They were getting on famously. But then “we tried to negotiate peace, and we failed, essentially on the right of return, which although obviously a legitimate demand among the Palestinians, means the destruction of Israel. So people who don’t want Israel destroyed cannot accept the right of return, even though they might understand that it has legitimacy behind it.”

Source: Daniel Kahneman: ‘What would I eliminate if I had a magic wand? Overconfidence’ | Books | The Guardian
HatTip to Dave Lull

As technology increases, misunderstanding of ruin by a very small number of people is sufficient to guarantee ruin

https://twitter.com/nntaleb/status/622407350482305024

https://twitter.com/nntaleb/status/622375840144302080

https://twitter.com/nntaleb/status/622127777064595456

As technology increases, misunderstanding of ruin by a very small number of people is sufficient to guarantee ruin Greece: Neither those who made the decision to borrow nor those who made the decision to lend had skin in the game. “Other people’ money”.
Friday probability quiz. X has 2 children. One of them is a girl. What is the probability of the other one being a girl?