Would-be Error Detectors: Suit Up | AllAboutAlpha

Taleb writes thus: “Many have the illusion that ‘because Kolmogorov-Smirnov is nonparametric’, it is therefore immune to the nature specific distribution under the test….”

What does that mean? The Kolmogorov-Smirnov test is a standard measure of how a certain data sample compares with a reference probability distribution. It focuses on the largest observed distance between the actual set and the corresponding figure in the referenced distribution. If the largest observed distance is acceptably low, then presumably the one is acceptably conformable to the other. This test is widely said to be “non-parametric,” which in this context means that it is free of question-begging assumptions.

So what Taleb contends here is that the nonparametric nature of that test is an illusion. This is part of his effort to discredit patch-up jobs. In his view, Kolmogorov-Smirnov is one of many ways in which quants persuade themselves that they at last have a fix on how fat those fat tails can really get. If true, this would allow the quants to return to their pre-crisis mechanical ideas about risk management. But it isn’t, and they shouldn’t.

Or, as Taleb puts it at his most eloquent, “Shkmolgorov-Smirnoff.” Though I’m not sure I could manage the pronunciation of that.

via Would-be Error Detectors: Suit Up | AllAboutAlpha: Hedge Fund Trends & Alternative Investment Analysis.

Taleb, Mystery and Conservatism | The Brussels Journal

‘Optionality’ involves recognizing the unexpected and unpredictable consequences of trial and error tinkering. Most inventions and discoveries are chance events; intelligence is involved in recognizing a good thing when you see it, even though you weren’t expecting it.
…
So intelligence is employed in employing optionality, rather than needing a correct theory that explains why everything is the way it is, usually impossible, or predicting the future. Taleb’s recommendation is to rely on empirical observation as much as possible and to be skeptical about theories. Theories come and go, but the empirical remains stable. Weight training, properly done, will increase muscle size and strength. We don’t know why. Theories as to why are fragile. Today you get one explanation, tomorrow a new one.

via Taleb, Mystery and Conservatism | The Brussels Journal.
HatTip to Dave Lull

It is easy for others, but not for you…

It is easy for others, but not for you, to detect the asymmetry between what you gain and what you give by doing, writing or saying.

—

COMMENT ON THE ASYMMETRY: The most convincing statements are those in which you stand to lose (maximal skin in the game); the most unconvincing ones are those in which you patently (but unknowingly) try to enhance your status without contribution (like the great majority of academic papers that say nothing and take no risks); but it doesn’t have to be that way. As long as the substance and gain for others exceeds the showoff content, you are OK. Stay human, take as much as you can, under the condition you give more than you take.

—

EARLIER APHORISM: Anything people do, write, or say to enhance their status or distinction shows like a mark on their foreheads, more visible to others than it is to them.

(modified)

via It is easy for others, but not for you, to… – Nassim Nicholas Taleb.