All the education in the world will not compensate for a logical fallacy…

All the education in the world will not compensate for a logical fallacy, of the style: “All members of the Smith family are tall; he is tall *hence* he is a member of the Smith family”, the central error in Fooled by Randomness (and the main reason for underestimation of luck).

—

For, I am unhappy to report, many people make it in real life, along with its variations. Further, this is not just journalism: I saw it made just so frequently by PhDs (in the GMO and Pinker debates) that I am totally disgusted: better be a truck driver with logical abilities, than a PhD with such elementary defects. Indeed it is so prevalent in social science it is not even funny.

—

Finally, I find it horrifying that people make it here on this page (these people are now gone). Forget all the complicated stuff, focus on the elementary, the basic, for Baal’s sake.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Affirming_the_consequent

Affirming the consequent – Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Affirming the consequent, sometimes called converse error or fallacy of the converse, is a formal fallacy of inferring the converse from the original statement. The corresponding argument has the general form:

via All the education in the world will not… – Nassim Nicholas Taleb.

LINDY FOR THE DETECTION of MODERN BULLSHIT

LINDY FOR THE DETECTION of MODERN BULLSHIT.

It is a (sort of) truism that we make the mistake of thinking of the past in terms entire made in the present, making the mistake of propagating backwards such notions as “religion”, “values”, “Gods”, “success”, “happiness”, “ambition”, “meaning of life”, and attribute it to motives of action, when these either didn’t mean much for people in the middle ages and antiquity or had different significance for them. For instance, for Semites, religion meant “law”, didn’t have the spiritual dimension we attribute today; it didn’t care of the notion of “belief” (and Christianity didn’t have a word for it other than “trust”). For pagans, Gods were cultural artifacts… For Romans, freedom meant not being a slave and *having no debt*.

—

What I am now trying to do, in a systematic way, is the opposite operation, that is, to reexpress the present entirely in terms that an ancient person would have grasped, that is, to propagate the mentality forward, while incorporating modern gains in ethics such as “equality”, social justice, etc.

—

So using Lindy as a bullshit detection mechanism, I can eliminate modern notions such as “success”, “achievement”, etc., those that do not have a moral dimension.

via LINDY FOR THE DETECTION of MODERN BULLSHIT. It… – Nassim Nicholas Taleb.
Lindy Effect

Rest in Peace, Jacques Le Goff, Medieval Historian, Luminous Mind.

Rest in Peace, Jacques Le Goff, Medieval Historian, Luminous Mind.
—
He is the author of this passage on the contrast between the true scholar and the professor:

“There is nothing more striking than the contrast between images which show the intellectual in the Middle Ages and the humanist at work. The former is a professor, caught up in his teaching (…) The other is a solitary scholar, in his calm chamber, at ease in the midst of the private, luxurious room where his thoughts can move freely about. The former shows the tumult of schools, the dust of classrooms, the collective worker’s indifference to beauty,

The latter shows all is order and beauty,

“Luxe calme et volupté”

I wish you eternal “Luxe calme et volupté”, Jacques Le Goff.

http://lyonelkaufmann.ch/histoire/2014/04/01/jacques-le-goff-1924-2014-leclaireur-du-moyen-age/

Jacques Le Goff (1924-2014) : L’éclaireur du Moyen-Âge

Jacques Le Goff (1924-2014) AFP/JACQUES SASSIER Certes, vu l’âge du bonhomme (90 ans), plus le temps avançait et plus l’inéluctable devait arriver,…

via Rest in Peace, Jacques Le Goff, Medieval… – Nassim Nicholas Taleb.